Keyword Cannibalization

What Is Keyword Cannibalization?

Keyword cannibalization happens when two or more pages on the same site target the same or very similar keywords, causing them to compete against each other in search results instead of one clear page ranking strongly.

How It Hurts Rankings

When multiple pages compete for the same query, search engines have to choose which one to rank, and that choice can shift over time — splitting authority, confusing relevance signals, and often resulting in both pages ranking worse than a single, consolidated page would.

How to Fix It

Start by identifying overlapping pages (a site audit or a simple site: search in Google often reveals it). From there, either consolidate the content into one strong page and 301 redirect the weaker one, or clearly differentiate the pages by search intent and keyword focus if there’s a genuine reason for both to exist. Updating internal links to point consistently to the page you want to rank also helps signal which one should win.

Table of Contents

Annabelle Cochrane

Managing Director / SEO Strategist

Annabelle is a qualified marketing specialist with over 6 years of hands-on experience providing service-based businesses with real, tangible, out-come based SEO campaigns. 

more insights

seo for law firms

Law Firm SEO: The Complete Guide for Australian Lawyers (2026)

This guide is general marketing information, not legal advice. Check your obligations with your Law Society or regulator. Legal searches are some of the most valuable searches in Google. A single new matter can be worth thousands, sometimes tens of thousands, of dollars, which is exactly why the competition is

Read more >
How to Measure SEO Success: The ALC Outcome Ladder

How to Measure SEO Success: The ALC Outcome Ladder

Most SEO reports answer the wrong question. They tell you how busy someone was, or how many keywords moved, and leave you guessing whether any of it brought in work. After four years in agency and now running ALC, I measure SEO with a simple model I call the ALC

Read more >

Why I’ll Never Track Time on Client Work

I don’t track my time on client work. Not as a KPI, not as a log, not as a number on a report. I never will. That sounds like an odd thing to say about running an SEO business, so let me explain where it comes from. How I Got

Read more >